The pros and cons of Daylight Saving Time
In a few countries DST has become a political power struggle, while others debate whether setting the clocks one hour ahead in the spring has the intended effect of conserving energy or reducing road accidents.
Ever since the very first time Daylight Saving Time (DST) was introduced in Germany in 1916, during World War I, people have disagreed about whether setting the clocks one hour forward in the spring, and back again in the fall, has the desired effect.
More natural light
Over 70 countries use DST today, mainly to:
- Make better use of natural daylight.
- Conserve energy otherwise spent on artificial light.
- Decrease road accidents by making sure roads are naturally lit during the hours with most traffic.
Daylight hours vary
The argument of using DST to make better use of the natural daylight in the evenings makes most sense in the areas furthest away from the Earth's equator. This is where there is the biggest difference in the number of daylight hours in winter and summer.
Daylight hours examples:
- Sunrise & Sunset in Tromsø, Norway, October
- Sunrise & Sunset in Seattle, USA, November
- Sunrise & Sunset in Quito, Ecuador, November
- Sunrise & Sunset in Cape Town, Souh Africa, October
Upsets milking cows
Traditional dairy farmers often protest that changing the clocks one hour twice a year makes milking cows and getting the milk collected in time a challenge. In more modern dairy farms, the cows are milked at will by robots and this argument becomes void. However, farmers in developing countries are still an active part of the debate.
Presidential power struggle
Since January 2011, Russia has been through several changes in their DST schedule, causing both protests and unrest, before President Vladimir Putin decided to return to permanent Standard Time (aka Winter Time) in October 2014.
In Muslim countries, like for instance Morocco, they suspend DST during Ramadan and start again once the month is over.
Losing U.S. popularity
According to a Rasmussen Report from 2013, only 37 % of Americans see the purpose of DST compared to 45 % the year before.
There are many positives to the extra hour of daylight, especially in every day life:
- Studies link DST to reduced road injuries. A joint Transport Research Laboratory and University College of London study predicted that fewer people would be killed and injured in road accidents if one hour of daylight was transferred from the morning to the afternoon.
- The tourist industry welcomes DST, claiming that the extra hour of sunlight makes people stay out later, thus spending more money on activites like festivals, shopping and concerts.
The Belfast Telegraph reports that the extra evening light gives Northern Ireland at least £6.34 million a year in extra cash from tourists.
In Australia, the New South Wales state government announced that an extra four weeks of DST would boost retail and tourism. According to the Courier Mail, Queensland's lack of Daylight Saving is costing the economy an estimated $4 billion a year in lost business.
Energy efficient, or not?
DST is often linked to energy saving, but there still is disagreement as to if theory matches practice.
- Pro DST arguments are that more light can counteract blackouts and other electrical failures that can occur later in the day and that it influences people to spend more time out of the house, thus using less lighting and electrical appliances.
- In countries such as Canada, Cuba, Chile, Argentina, Mexico, the United States and other parts of the world, DST is used as a means of conserving energy as the demand for electricity and gas increases.
Arguments against DST include:
- Safety concerns – People are leaving their homes when it is still dark in the mornings, thus being exposed to crime. Guatemala decided not to have DST in 2008 because of safety concerns.
- Health concerns – Studies show that there is an increase in both heart attacks and road accidents on the days after clocks are set forward one hour in the spring.
In this Article
- Daylight hours vary
- Upsets milking cows
- Presidential power struggle
- Losing U.S. popularity
- Energy efficient, or not?
- History of DST
- History of DST in Europe
- Your Health and DST
- Controversy of DST
- 1 Hour Back or Forward?
- Summer or Winter Time?
- Savings or Saving?
- DST in the US Changed in 2005